How To Choose The Best Organic Crib Mattress Protector/Cover

An organic crib mattress protector/cover is a must have item if you want a healthier environment for your baby during sleep. While it is a very reasonable investment, some parents consider it unnecessary or too expensive to buy. Interestingly, those same parents take the time to find a crib mattress made of high-quality materials.

An organic crib mattress protector is not just a cover for your baby’s mattress. It helps your child feel comfortable while sleeping. It helps prevent allergic reactions, creates a healthy sleeping environment, protects against liquids, and helps keep dust mites at bay. They are made of healthy, chemical-free materials, which improves the baby’s sleep quality even more.

Things to Consider When Buying an Organic Crib Mattress Protector

Once you have made the decision to buy an organic mattress protector, you will need to determine what type you need. Here are important things to consider to make the right choice.


You need to determine where you will be using the mattress protector since the type of material will depend on the use. If you haven’t bought the mattress yet, you need to determine whether you want the crib mattress protector for the diaper changing table or for the baby’s crib.


Do you want a zippered pad or a fitted pad like a bag where you put the mattress of the crib? You can also choose the option with elastic bands on the edges. If your baby moves a lot while sleeping, the choice of attachment is an important consideration since it helps prevent the protector from sliding.

crib mattress protectorColor

It is obvious that you wouldn’t choose a brightly colored mattress cover for sleep. However, you will still find crib light colored mattress protectors on the market and others with colorful prints. You can choose such options if you don’t want the traditional white color.


The money you have available to spend on the crib mattress protector will ultimately determine the quality of protector you end up buying. If expensive products made in the USA are beyond your budget, you can consider buying imported alternatives of similar quality but more affordable.

Organic Mattress Cover Reviews

Naturepedic Waterproof Crib Pad

Naturepedic Waterproof Crib Pad is a 100 percent organic mattress crib cover. The materials used to make the protector are GreenGuard tested, which is a sign of quality and a guarantee that only minimal environmental harm has happened in the manufacturing process.

Naturepedic Waterproof Crib PadNaturepedic Waterproof Crib Pad provides a hypoallergenic and waterproof barrier that keeps liquids, dust mites, and other potential allergens away. It is breathable and ensures that your baby enjoys a restful night of sleep without sweating.

It is suitable for nearly all types of crib mattresses. Users report that it is soft to the touch thanks to the organic cotton fabric. The fact that it is a made in the USA product makes it a highly desirable option for most parents.

Serta Perfect Balance Deluxe Organic Crib Mattress Pad

If you would like to strike a balance between functionality and comfort, the Serta Perfect Balance is a great option. It features a plush, soft, pure organic cotton upper layer while its lining is made of waterproof material that offers complete protection against liquids.

Serta Perfect Balance Deluxe Organic Crib Mattress PadThe Serta Perfect Balance crib mattress pad absorbs well but it still can be washed easily and dries comparatively fast. It features elastic bands on the edges that prevent it from sliding down. The bands also make it suitable for all types of crib mattresses.

The Serta Perfect Balance is quite a good deal for the price. It has been praised for its appearance since it is available in 2 colors and has a cute print on the top. It is a very high quality and appears to be quite durable.

I’m a Little Teapot! Crib Mattress Pad

Filled with 100 percent organic cotton, this crib mattress pad is pleasant to the touch and extremely soft, which ensures more comfortable sleep for your baby. Strong seams support the high-quality Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)-Certified fabric.

It is free of chemicals including Phthalates, BPA, Latex, Vinyl, etc., which means that it does not have a chemical smell. It is a wonderful product that comes with a 12-month, money back guarantee meaning that you can use it without worry.

The crib mattress protector has been praised for its affordability and efficiency. Parents love the quality of the material and the fact that it doesn’t shrink after washing several times. It can be washed in warm or cold water instead of hot.

Brooklyn Bamboo Organic Mattress Protector

mattressThe Brooklyn Bamboo is different from the other organic mattress protectors on this list since it is made of soft, organic bamboo fabric. The crib mattress protector is free of harmful chemicals and prevents allergic reactions from affecting your baby’s sleep.

It features a non-toxic and environmentally-friendly waterproof layer that prevents leaks and guarantees a restful night of sleep for your baby. It is machine washable so that you can keep it clean and so that it may serve you for a long time. It is an imported product.

The organic bamboo used to make the Brooklyn Bamboo crib mattress protector is more durable and absorbent than cotton. It fits most crib mattresses and does not show through the sheets despite the fact that it is yellow in color. It also resists dirty stains and dust successfully.

American Baby Company Organic Mattress Pad

American Baby Company Organic Mattress PadThis organic crib mattress protector has the highest ratings in this list of organic mattress protectors. It is made of breathable polyester and a soft organic cotton cover. This unique blend of fibers makes it the most durable and safest organic mattress pad.

The American Baby Company Organic crib mattress protector is Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified, which means that it contains at least 70 percent organic material. The protector is easily washable to ensure hygiene around your baby.

It features a great waterproof lining, which means that it is highly effective in terms of protecting against liquids. Parents also love the fact that the American Baby Company Organic crib mattress protector does not make any noise when their babies move in their cribs.


Safety is what everybody is after in the modern world and this applies to babies and children too. Your child spends so many hours of the day sleeping and it is important to provide a safe, hygienic environment inside the crib. An organic mattress protector/cover does exactly that. It protects your child and performs many important functions. Follow the tips discussed here to find the best organic crib mattress cover/ protector for your baby and take the 5 protectors reviewed here into consideration.

Previous articleBest Crib Mattress: Buyer’s Guide
I am Merlie Tracey, a certified sleep specialist with a lot of experience and a professional background in psychology. Upon having graduated from the UCLA, I decided to take my career as a psychologist to a different level and expanded by learning more about sleep therapy. Working with patients from all walks of life, soon I have realized how important sleep actually was for normal functioning.