If you are a new parent, you have probably bought a crib and mattress where the baby will be sleeping on. However, like most new parents, you might have forgotten an equally important purchase, which is the crib mattress pad.

Just as adults love having an additional layer between themselves and their mattress, a crib mattress pad is a thin protective layer that lies underneath the bed sheet and on top of the mattress. It is designed to provide an additional layer of comfort for the baby. The best mattress pads are actually hypoallergenic and waterproof.

Babies have very sensitive skin at their tender ages, which means that a thin protective layer between their bodies and the mattress is an important protective device that helps prevent any injuries or nasty skin irritations.

These kind of products should ideally be washable, which makes it easier to wash and remove vomit, urine, and other stains as opposed to from the mattress itself. They also provide a protective layer between your baby and any bacterial growth from the crib mattress.

Types of Crib Mattress Pads

Crib mattress pads can be generally divided into 2 main categories: thin, cushioned pads, and the sheet savers, which are more practical. Sheet savers are placed either underneath the bed sheet or on top of it while the pads are always placed between the bed sheet and the mattress.

The type of pad for the mattress you choose for your baby depends on your preferences. Sheet savers are generally one useful for doing just that, which is saving the sheets from any baby accidents. Cushioned pads are designed to lend some degree of comfort to the mattress.

The Best Crib Mattress Pad Buying Guide

The best crib mattress pad will be completely safe and will provide several benefits for your baby. As a parent, it is important to ensure that your child enjoys enough restorative sleep and is as happy as possible in his or her bassinet or crib.

Here are the key features to look out for when searching for the best mattress pad for your baby’s crib:

he-Best-Crib-Mattress-Pad-Buying-Guide Hypoallergenic

– Waterproof

– Baby Safe

– Comfortable

– Noiseless

– Washable

‘Baby Safe’ here refers to mattress pads that stay in place under the sheet and will not affect or alter your baby’s breathing in any way. You probably realize that babies can be quite wriggly and you thus need to find a mattress pad that stays in place under the bed sheet.

Crib Mattress Pad Reviews

PUREgrace Crib Mattress Pad

If you would like the best crib mattress pad for your baby, you cannot go wrong if you choose this incredible product from PUREgrace.

It is an incredibly high-quality mattress pad made from all natural TENCEL (Eucalyptus based fibers). It comes with an impressive 10-year warranty and is hypoallergenic, waterproof, and soft.

The Good

PUREgrace-Crib-Mattress-Pad– 10-Year Warranty

– Naturally Hypoallergenic

– Machine Washable

– BPA, Phthalates, PVC, and Vinyl Free

– Safe, Quiet Waterproof Layer

– Easy to Secure to the Crib Mattress

– TENCEL Fabric is Grown Free of Herbicides and Pesticides

The Bad

– Padding is somewhat thin meaning that it doesn’t revolutionize comfort levels

Dry Defender Organic Cotton Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad

The Dry Defender mattress pad for the crib is a luxuriously designed product and one of the best in the market, guaranteeing zero penetration of liquid to your crib mattress, and offering 4 layers of protection.

The Dry Defender pad is especially popular with parents that prefer effective natural baby supplies since it is made of soft, non-toxic, organic, unbleached cotton.

The Good

– Fits Snugly to Crib Mattress

– The Inner Polyester Layer is Highly Absorbent

Dry Defender Organic Cotton Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad– 4 Layers of Waterproof Protection

– Super Soft to the Touch

– Hypoallergenic Top Made Using Organic Knit Cotton Jersey

– 100 Percent Waterproof and No Liquid Penetration

– Made from Unbleached, Non-Toxic, Organic Cotton

– Dryer Friendly and Machine Washable

The Bad

– A Bit Thin

– Must Be Washed Cold to Prevent Shrinkage

Sealy Stain Protection Crib Mattress Pad

The main selling point of the Sealy Stain crib mattress pad is that it keeps your crib mattress pristine even in the face of some baby accidents by repelling stains. It also remains secure to the crib mattress and is waterproof and hypoallergenic. The crib mattress pad does exactly what it says on the packaging.

The Good

Sealy Stain Protection Crib Mattress PadLead and PVC Free

– Quilted Hypoallergenic Filling

– Fits Snugly to the Crib Mattress Due to the Deep Pocketed Skirts

– Inexpensive

– Excellent Stain Repelling Properties

– Dryer Friendly and Machine Washable

– Complete Waterproof Protection

The Bad

– Not as durable as the rest of the pads on this list

– Not as soft or thick as other pads on this list

Baby and Brooke Organic Crib Mattress Pad

The Baby and Brooke Organic Crib Mattress Pad is hypoallergenic, antibacterial, and soft to the touch and it is not a wonder that parents love it so much. It does not contain any plastic meaning that your baby’s sleep won’t be interrupted by crinkling noises.

The Good

– Easy to Clean

– No Initial Odors

Baby and Brooke Organic Crib Mattress PadLead, Vinyl, Fire Retardant, Latex, BPA, and Phthalate Free

– Noiseless

– Fits Snugly to Crib Mattress

– Highly Absorbent and Completely Waterproof

– Breathable, Super Soft Bamboo Fabric

– Hypoallergenic and Antibacterial

The Bad

– Not Dryer Friendly

Nursery Necessities Crib Mattress Pad

The Nursery Necessities crib mattress pad is one of the most popular options on the market. It is made using quality, breathable microfiber fabric and promises to keep your child warm during the cold season and cool in the hot season. It is very reasonably priced and hypoallergenic, which makes it a great choice if your baby has sensitive skin or allergies.

The Good

– Dryer Friendly and Machine Washable

– BPA, Vinyl, PVC, Phthalate, and Flame Retardant Free

Nursery Necessities Crib Mattress PadLifetime Satisfaction Guarantee

– Waterproof

– Fits Crib Mattress Snugly

– Antimicrobial and Hypoallergenic

– No Crinkling Sounds

– Highly Durable

– Made of Microfiber Fabric

– Soft and Quilted

The Bad

– While it is quilted, it is still quite thin meaning that it doesn’t impact the comfort level of the crib mattress a great deal.


Your new bundle of joy spends 16 hours each day on average in his or her crib. It is thus important and makes sense to buy the best crib mattress pad possible. Use the information provided here to help you find the best mattress pad for your baby’s crib and you can use the 5 options discussed here as a starting point for your search.

Next articleIs it Safe to Paint a Crib?
I am Merlie Tracey, a certified sleep specialist with a lot of experience and a professional background in psychology. Upon having graduated from the UCLA, I decided to take my career as a psychologist to a different level and expanded by learning more about sleep therapy. Working with patients from all walks of life, soon I have realized how important sleep actually was for normal functioning.